Sunday, April 8, 2012

Drilling and Hydraulic Fracturing: A Benefit for Struggling Economies (ENGL102)

For my English 102 class... an argument on fracking, following the Toulmin form...


Drilling and Hydraulic Fracturing: A Benefit for Struggling Economies
            The term is all over the news, local and national: fracking. It is a word heard in every area of the country that has some form of natural gas and oil drilling. As these areas of drilling spread from the southern parts of America into the northeast, fracking has become a hot subject for debate. Many people feel that fracking should not be disallowed, but hydraulic fracturing is a necessary part of the process of natural gas and oil drilling. Not only does it allow energy resources to be retrieved that were inaccessible before, but it provides many economic benefits for the areas that allow the process, an important advantage during times of economic struggle.
            Fracking, or the proper term, hydraulic fracturing, involves injecting water, sand, and a special mix of chemicals into drilling wells. This combination of water, sand and chemicals is injected with tremendous amounts of pressure to fracture geological formations, such as rock, coal beds and shale underground. This allows the oil or gas beneath the rock to flow into the production well. The remaining water and chemicals are then pumped back to the surface to be disposed of through either treatment or deep well injection (“Hydraulic”). Because fracking allows previously unreachable energy resources to be tapped, it has played a major part in the growth of the gas and oil industry, especially in the development in the Marcellus Shale, which is thought to be the largest natural gas underground reservoir in the United States.
            With the use of fracking, additional energy resources are able to be expanded, reached and used to create more energy for consumers across America, harnessing a cleaner energy than petroleum or coal, and doing it domestically. As unconventional sources are found, wells are built and hydraulic fracturing is used to access them. The number of wells in the United States has increased from about 260,000 wells to almost 500,000 in the space of ten years, ninety percent of which use hydraulic fracturing to access these sources, such as tight sand, the largest, and shale, like the Marcellus Shale, the fastest growing (“Hydraulic”). Pennsylvania alone issues about 2,500 permits a year to various companies to drill in the Marcellus Shale (Skirble). Without fracking, reservoirs like the Marcellus Shale would not be readily accessible. Hydraulic fracturing has increased domestic production of natural gas by almost twenty percent, bringing about lower prices that are staying steady. In fact, the prices of natural gas are almost fifty percent less than they were just five years previous (McCurdy D1). Not only have prices dropped, but America has been able to add to its reserves and now has, “sufficient natural gas resources to last approximately 110 years” (“Fracking”)
            As these new wells and drilling sites are created, so are many new jobs. In Pennsylvania, the drilling industry will create approximately 88,000 new jobs just this year and is predicted to create 250,000 in the next ten years (“Opportunity”). In a report from the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry hiring is, “nearly double in 2011 than what it was in 2012” (qtd. in “No”) resulting an unemployment rate under the national average. Companies that supply safety equipment, construction equipment, welding and metal manufacturers, and especially heavy duty trucks are all hiring more employees or to keep up with demand and new companies are being started all the time. Somerset Welding and Steel and J&J Truck bodies and Trailers were able to rehire many of the staff they had been forced to lay off in previous years. Heavy truck drivers, comprising ten percent of people involved in the drilling sites, are seeing an especially high demand because of fracking and the large amounts of water that need to be transported to and from sites. Engineering firms, such as L. Robert Kimball, are aiding with mapping and designing sites and transportation lines. These jobs are not just directly related to working in the field – many business associated indirectly with the industry are hiring for new jobs as their business demands increase. Banks such as S&T and First Commonwealth are hiring people with backgrounds in the industry to assist with related services like lending to gas-related businesses and services for landowners that lease property for mineral extraction. Law firms are also hiring professionals with a legal background in land acquisition and specialized contracts (“Opportunity”).
These businesses are not just able to employ more people – they are also seeing an increase in profits and revenue. Dale Oxygen, in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, saw in increase in business of twenty percent in 2010 because of an increased demand for the equipment and products it supplies. In a Penn State study it was founds that during the year of 2008, Pennsylvania received $240 million in taxes and that the gas industry had a $2.3 billion value. Pennsylvania predicts a payoff of $13.5 billion by 2020 (“No”).  Water companies and local municipal authorities benefit from fracking, also: they sell the massive amounts of water needed to create the fracturing process. Businesses localized around drilling areas are also seeing profits derived from the employees of the gas sites. People from other fields brought in to assist need a place to stay, so hotels, motels, and rental properties see a steady profit. With the increase in people in the area, business such as grocery stores, gas stations, and restaurants also see an increase.
Many people do not feel that the economical benefits are enough to justify the process of hydraulic fracturing. They feel these benefits are outweighed by the possible environmental repercussions. The main environmental concern is whether hydraulic fracturing contaminates the drinking water supply. There have been reports that in areas utilizing the fracking process, methane levels and/or chemical contamination found in drinking. In Pennsylvania, it was confirmed that methane had leaked into water sources. However, instances of contamination are not directly leaked to the process of hydraulic fracturing but to faulty construction and failures of the well’s pipe or cement casing. Contamination has also been linked to above ground spills at drilling sites. These causes are much more of a risk than hydraulic fracturing. Charles Groat, associate director of the Energy Institute at the University of Texas at Austin, says that, “These problems are not unique to hydraulic fracturing” (qtd. Vaughan 1A).
Perhaps instead of banning the process of hydraulic fracturing, states should work harder to enforce regulations uncompromisingly. By making sure to enforce the regulations that are already in effect while awaiting stronger regulations, these state could possibly minimize an oversights by the drilling companies. As well as following the regulations, the gas industry could also help minimize its impact on the environment and maintaining a more positive image by taking full responsibility to any previously unintentionial contamination issues and having a more transparent façade by allowing the public to become familiar with its processes and disclosing  the chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing. By enforcing regulations, maintain strict safety and quality control,  and keeping the public informed, local communities can enjoy the economic benefits of hydraulic fracturing while seeing their environment preserved.
Works Cited
"An opportunity that cannot be ignored." Tribune-Democrat. 01 05 2011: n. page. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
"Fracking and Drinking Water Safety." Congressional Digest. 91.3 (2012): n. page. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
"Hydraulic Fracturing Overview." Congressional Digest. 91.3 (2012): n. page. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
McCurdy, Dave. "Is hydraulic fracturing too dangerous? NO: It's a safe process that results in needed energy." Denver Post 10 07 2011. D1. LexisNexis. Web. 1 Apr 2012.
"No: Fracking is Energy’s Economic Goldmine." policymic. 08 2011: n. page. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
Skirble, Rosanne. Study: No Evidence Hydraulic Fracturing Pollutes Water. Lanham, United States, Lanham:, 2012. ProQuest Military Collection; ProQuest Research Library. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
Vaughan, Vicki. "Study finds that fracking itself does not pollute groundwater." San Antonio Express-News 17 02 2011. 1A. LexisNexis. Web. 1 Apr 2012.

No comments:

Post a Comment